Gary Wayne Sutton has spent more than three decades on Tennessee’s death row for two 1992 murders in East Tennessee. His case has drawn growing attention because of serious questions about the evidence used to convict him and the reliability of key testimony presented to the jury.
The prosecution’s case relied heavily on a disputed timeline rather than physical or forensic evidence directly tying Gary Wayne Sutton to the crimes. Supporters and defense filings have long argued that there was no direct physical evidence connecting him to the murders.
Central to the State’s timeline was testimony from a medical examiner whose credibility later collapsed. That medical examiner would go on to lose his license and become associated with misconduct in other cases. At the time of trial, the jury was not informed of these credibility issues.
Independent reporting and court records indicate:
– No direct physical evidence linking Gary Wayne Sutton to the crimes
– A prosecution theory built around contested time-of-death assumptions
– Key forensic testimony later shown to come from a discredited source
– Unresolved questions about whether critical information was withheld from the jury
Despite these unresolved issues, Gary Wayne Sutton remains under a sentence of death, with an execution date now set as Tennessee resumes executions following a statewide pause.
This Faces of Injustice file is currently under development. Trial transcripts, forensic records, post-conviction filings, and additional documentation are being requested and reviewed. This summary will be updated as source materials are verified.
GET INVOLVED / LEARN MORE
Official case advocacy site:
https://www.justiceforgarywaynesutton.com/
Public petition calling for relief and review:
https://www.change.org/FreeGarySutton
Additional media coverage and investigative reporting links will be added as records are reviewed and verified.
Comments